Skip to content
Back to the blog

Both sectors2 min read

Counter-offers: why we bring them up in the first interview

A strong candidate who's currently employed will get a counter-offer. The question isn't whether it comes, but what they'll do that day. We'd rather talk about it early.

By Karen WhitfieldSenior director, Ontario

The people we recruit aren't looking for jobs. They're good, they're employed, and their employer has no interest in losing them. When they hand in their resignation, the counter-offer often arrives within 48 hours.

Why we raise it early

In the first interview we ask a simple question: “What would have to change at your current employer for you to stay?” If the answer is “better pay”, we note it, because a counter-offer will fix exactly that. If the answer is about leadership, the plant's future or how decisions get made, no cheque will change the situation.

What a counter-offer doesn't fix

A raise doesn't change the reporting line, doesn't unlock the capital budget and doesn't replace the boss it isn't working with anymore. In the months that follow, the person who accepted the counter-offer often finds themselves with the same reasons to leave, and less of their employer's trust.

What we do with the employer

  • We build the counter-offer into the timeline: the written offer comes fast and the start date is realistic.
  • We make sure the offer answers the real reasons for leaving, not just the salary.
  • We stay in touch with the candidate between the resignation and day one. It's the most fragile stretch of the whole process.

A counter-offer isn't a betrayal. It's a test. The candidate who saw it coming already knows what to say.

A role to fill, or a career to move forward?

Get in touch. We reply within one business day.